Buy viagra
j

Monthly Archive for March, 2009

“Reading James With New Eyes” Reviewed

Peter Frick of Conrad Grebel University College at the University of Waterloo has reviewed Reading James With New Eyes, a volume I have previously discussed, in the Review of Biblical Literature. The review is available here.

Frick provides a summary of the essays while noting his reservations with new methodological approaches, namely that the methods lead the authors to different places with regard to James’ central focus. After 2 lengthy paragraphs criticizing the essays, he concludes with a two sentence conclusion espousing the timeliness of the work.

On a personal note, after taking midterms and grading midterms, spring break, and a minor family emergency, I am back in the blogging saddle.

The Testament of Job as a hypotext for the Letter of James

To continue my discussion of Jacobean verbal icons, I would like to point to the possible relationship between the thought world of the author of James and the body of work known was the Testament of Job (TJob).

In James 5:11, the author references Job as a model of perseverance: “Indeed we call blessed those who showed endurance. You have heard of the endurance of Job, and you have seen the purpose of the Lord, how the Lord is compassionate and merciful” (NRSV).

For the auditors of this text, the reference to the person of Job would have been understood in light of canonical Job, certainly, but possibly in light of the intertestamental Testament of Job as well. Questions remain about the writing’s date of compilation, but the story certainly existed in oral form before redaction, so a first century Jewish audience very well could have been familiar with it.

In the closing part of his letter, James speaks of faith and suffering, and he uses Job as a verbal icon that illustrates the purpose of the Lord, particularly with reference to compassion and mercy (πολύσπλαγχνός ἐστιν ὁ κύριος καὶ οἰκτίρμων).

In TJob, the theme of Job’s compassion and mercy recur throughout.  James, then, in his effort to promote the plight of the marginalized, namely the πτωχοι, elevates the person of Job as a verbal icon of perseverance amidst suffering that illustrates the compassion and mercy of God, all of which are traits the author desire’s to inspire in his auditors.

Verbal icons, then, provide the author with a means of communicating layers of meaning and rich significance unachievable through simple comparisons.

Here are a few examples of Job’s disposition toward the poor:

And I had three hundred and forty thousand nomadic asses, and of these I set aside five hundred, and the offspring of these I order to he sold and the proceeds to be given to the poor and the needy. For from all the lands the many came to meet me.6 For the four doors of my house were opened, each, being in charge of a watchman who had to see whether there were any people coming asking alms, and whether they would see me sitting at one of the door’s so that they could leave through the other and take whatever they needed. (3:5–9)

I also had three thousand five hundred yokes of oxen, and I selected of these five hundred and had them tend to the plowing. And with these I had done all the work in each field by those who would, take it in charge and the income of their crops I laid aside for the poor on their table. I also had fifty bakeries from which I sent [the bread] to the table for the poor. (10:5–6)

I therefore, rising early, would offer up sacrifices on their behalf in the following amounts: 300 doves, 50 goat’s kids, and 12 sheep. Everything over and above the prescribed ritual portion I would order to be considered superfluous and expended on the poor. (13:4–5)

On the board

So Much for Straw was mentioned on the February edition of The Biblioblog Top 50. Not actually on the list yet, but look out Ben Witherington!

Versput on Genre and Content

Genre
Versput discusses the generic nature of the Letter of James (Donald J. Versput, “Genre and Story: The Community Setting of the Epistle of James,” CBQ, 62 (2000): 96–110), and concludes that the designation ἐν τη διασπορα (in the dispersion/Diaspora) actually denotes the intended audience, rather than serving as a metaphorical designation only.

He finds generic parallels in the letter of Jeremiah in Jeremiah 29 as well as in the 2 Apocalypse of Baruch 78–89.  He points out that the latter example was written explicitly to be read aloud to communities in dispersion in order to encourage and exhort them amidst trials (101). Encouragement and hope thematically bind these writings, including James, together.

Content

Once establishing his stance on genre, Versput move to content. After claiming that the concerns of the author represent neither typical Jewish wisdom themes nor Christian paraenetic motifs (104), Versput emphasizes the communal concerns of the author: speech, leadership, and charity (105).

Versput’s conclusion, following Bo Reicke, is that the content of the Epistle of James shows similarity to the writings of ancient associations (collegia, θίασοι,
σύνοδοι), and offers ancient writings to lend support for his thesis.

While the style of the examples is markedly dry and distant (“let him this” or “if someone that,” opposed to the “my dear brothers” of James), Versput’s claim is that the parallel is in content and not necessarily style.

Interestingly, the same year this article was published (2000), JBL also carried an article on voluntary associations: Richard S. Ascough, “The Thessalonian Christian Community as a Professional Voluntary Association,” JBL 119, no. 2 (Summer, 2000), which is also a helpful read for anyone exploring the role of these associations in the ancient world.